Archive for the ‘3 out of 10’ Category

Comments Off on The Greatcoat by Helen Dunmore

The Greatcoat by Helen Dunmore


2012
08.15

“Mmmm where to start with this one? Helen Dunmore is a very well considered literary novelist and her novels The Siege and The Betrayal are absolutely worth the read. This is a departure to a ghost story.
The time is 1952 and a young married couple move to a Yorkshire village where he busies himself as the new doctor leaving his new wife to be just that. They rent rooms in a house with an odd landlady. When a Greatcoat is found it unlocks a ghostly visitor and the story develops from there.
Where I have a problem is that it isn’t sure if it’s a suspense or a romance, it’s intending to be both which doesn’t work for me, I’d signed up to have the shit scared out of me not worry if the husband will discover his wife’s upto something (or is she?)!

Score 3.5/10

Date read August 2012

What would your score for this book be? Please post your comments below.”

Comments Off on The Story of Beautiful Girl by Rachel Simon

The Story of Beautiful Girl by Rachel Simon


2012
07.15

“Set in 50’s America, a deaf man meets a mute girl in an asylum, they run away and get split up.
In true love style they never give up of finding each other.
Predictable and mediocre, poorly written, should have stayed in the ink cartridge.
Our book group gave this 4/10

Score 3/10

Date read July 2012

What would your score for this book be? Please post your comments below.”

Comments Off on The Man who went to Bed for a Year by Sue Townsend

The Man who went to Bed for a Year by Sue Townsend


2012
07.10

“I met Sue Townsend after reading this her latest novel. A remarkable woman, disabled by diabetes but undeterred with life. Her son takes dictation, but when I asked her if he adds any ideas or content the answer was a define NO!
This novel didn’t do it for me though I’d loved the Adrian Mole early books.
Pretty much the title tell the story… mundane stuff.

Score 3/10

Date read July 2012

What would your score for this book be? Please post your comments below.”

Comments Off on Tideline by Penny Hancock

Tideline by Penny Hancock


2012
02.20

“Implausible British thriller. Bored mother lures young lad into big old house on the river Thames.
Gradually (and it is gradually) we reach all the answers that we know are coming.
I’m a pretty harsh critic with thrillers, they have to have the thrill factor to achieve the thriller genre. This didn’t

Score 3/10

Date read February 2012

What would your score for this book be? Please post your comments below.”